Should our website ask people to call us, or to fill in a form?
Most business websites end up with a phone number in one corner, a form on another page and a "get in touch" button that could mean either. Here's a simple way to decide which route to lead with, how to make both work properly on a phone, and when a small tweak is all you need.
The managing director of an established building services firm asks: "Our website has a phone number and an enquiry form, and the buttons just say 'Contact us'. Some of the team want everyone to ring, others say the form is easier to manage. Which should the website be pushing people towards?"
It's a good question, because the answer shapes almost every button on the site. A website that can't decide tends to offer every option with equal weight, and visitors are left to work out the best route for themselves. Some won't bother.
The honest answer is that most businesses need both, but should lead with one. This article explains how to choose which, and how to make the other a clear second option rather than an afterthought.
Calls and forms suit different enquiries
Neither route is better in general. They suit different situations.
A phone call tends to work well when:
- The need is urgent, such as a leak, a breakdown or a same-week booking.
- The customer needs reassurance before they'll commit, and a quick conversation does that better than a page of text.
- The job is simple to scope by talking it through.
- Someone is reliably available to answer during the hours people are likely to ring.
A form tends to work well when:
- The job needs details, photos, measurements or documents before you can respond usefully.
- Customers are often researching out of hours, on an evening or weekend.
- Your team is on site or in meetings and can't pick up the phone promptly.
- You want every enquiry recorded in one place so it can be tracked and followed up.
Many established businesses sit somewhere in between: urgent work by phone, planned projects by form. That's fine, as long as the website makes the split obvious.
A quick decision framework
Answer these four questions about your typical enquiry:
- How urgent is it? If customers usually need help today, lead with the phone.
- How much information do you need before you can respond? If the answer is "quite a lot", lead with the form.
- Can someone answer the phone reliably? If calls often go to voicemail, leading with the phone may cost you more enquiries than it wins. Be honest here.
- What happens to each enquiry afterwards? If phone enquiries are scribbled on paper and forgotten, a form that lands in a shared inbox or CRM may serve customers better, even if a call feels more personal.
If most answers point one way, make that your primary call to action across the site. The other becomes the secondary option, clearly visible but less prominent.
Make the buttons say what they do
"Contact us" is vague. Visitors can't tell whether it rings a number, opens an email or takes them to a long form. Clearer labels set expectations and tend to feel less of a commitment:
- "Call 01234 567890" (with your real number) rather than "Contact us".
- "Request a quote" or "Send us your project details" for a form.
- "Book a site visit" if that's genuinely what happens next.
Next to a form, a short line saying what happens after someone submits it, for example "We reply within one working day", removes a lot of hesitation. Only promise what your team actually delivers.
Check how it works on a phone
Plenty of visitors will arrive on a mobile, so test both routes on your own phone:
- Is the phone number tappable? On a mobile, tapping the number should offer to call it. If it doesn't, it needs to be set up as a proper phone link. This is usually a small fix.
- Is the main button easy to find without scrolling far? A visitor shouldn't have to hunt for it.
- Does the form work comfortably on a small screen? Fields that are fiddly to tap, or a long form, can put people off. Our article on how many questions to put on your enquiry form covers how to keep it proportionate.
- Do your opening hours appear near the number? People are more likely to ring if they know someone will answer.
When a smaller change is enough
You may not need a redesign at all. If your site already gets reasonable enquiries and the issue is mainly unclear buttons, the following can often be done in an afternoon by whoever manages the site:
- Relabel vague "Contact us" buttons to say exactly what happens.
- Make the phone number tappable on mobile and show your hours beside it.
- Add one line under the form about when you'll reply.
A larger piece of work makes more sense when the problem runs deeper: for example, when enquiries from the form disappear into an inbox nobody checks, calls aren't recorded anywhere, or the site's structure means the main action is buried on most pages. In that case it's worth looking at the whole route from first visit to follow-up. Our guide on why a website gets visits but no enquiries is a good place to start, and our piece on what to put on your contact page covers the page many visitors land on last.
A worked example (hypothetical)
This is a hypothetical example to illustrate the approach. It isn't based on a real business or client.
Imagine a heating engineer in Devon who handles both emergency breakdowns and planned boiler replacements. The website has one "Contact us" button leading to a long form, and the phone number sits in small print in the footer.
Working through the four questions, the answer splits neatly. Breakdowns are urgent and simple to describe, so the breakdown page leads with a large, tappable "Call now" button and shows the hours the line is staffed. Boiler replacements need property details and photos, so those pages lead with "Request a replacement quote", a shorter form, and a line saying when the office will reply. The phone number stays visible on every page as the second option.
Nothing about the site's design changes. The difference is that each page now has one obvious next step that suits the kind of enquiry it attracts.
Your next step
Westward Digital builds websites and connected lead systems for established businesses across Somerset, Devon, Dorset, Bristol and Bath & North East Somerset, and business websites start from £4,500. If you'd like a straight view on whether your site needs clearer calls to action or a bigger rethink of how enquiries reach you, get in touch for a no-pressure conversation.
Working through something similar?
We can help you work out what to address first.