← All insights
Website & Conversion

Does our homepage make it clear what we do, who it's for and where we work, in the first few seconds?

Most people glance at the top of a homepage on their phone and decide whether to read on. Here's a simple "stranger test" you can run this week to find out whether yours says what you do, who it's for and where you work, plus a practical way to rewrite it. It's usually a wording and layout fix, not a rebuild.

A single clear pane of glass standing upright among scattered, softly blurred green, blue and cream glass discs, lit by warm morning light, suggesting clarity standing out from clutter

When you know your business inside out, it's very hard to see your own homepage the way a newcomer does. You read the headline and fill in everything you already know. A stranger only has what's on the screen, usually a phone screen, and often only the part they see before they scroll.

That's why the top of the homepage matters so much. It's where a visitor works out whether they've come to the right place. If it doesn't quickly answer three basic questions — what do you do, who is it for, and where do you work — some people will move on without ever reaching the good stuff further down.

The fix is rarely expensive. But you first need an honest view of what your homepage is actually saying, and you can't get that by reading it yourself.

Why owners can't judge their own homepage

Homepage headlines tend to drift away from plain description over time. A tagline chosen years ago, a slogan from a brochure, or a line about values ("Quality, care and commitment") can feel right to the people who wrote it. To a stranger, it says nothing about what you sell.

Common patterns include:

  • a headline that names the feeling but not the service ("Making spaces work beautifully")
  • a business name that doesn't explain itself, with nothing beside it that does
  • the service area mentioned only in the footer or on the contact page
  • a large rotating banner where the useful message appears on the third slide
  • several buttons competing for attention, so there's no obvious next step

None of these are wrong in themselves. The problem is when they take the space that should be answering the basic questions.

The stranger test: something you can run this week

You don't need software or a budget for this. You need a phone and three people who don't work in or with your business. Friends, neighbours or relatives are fine, as long as they don't already know what you do in detail. People who roughly match your customers are even better.

How to run it

  1. Open your homepage on a phone and scroll right to the top. Don't explain anything first beyond "I'd like your honest first impression of a website."
  2. Show it for about five seconds, then take the phone back. The short look is deliberate. You're testing what the top of the page says at a glance, not what someone could work out with time.
  3. Ask four questions, one at a time, and write down their answers word for word:
    • What do we do?
    • Who is it for?
    • Where do we work?
    • What would you do next?
  4. Don't correct or prompt them. If they're unsure, "I'm not sure" is a useful answer. Thank them and move on.

Do this with three people separately, so their answers don't influence each other. It takes a few minutes in total.

How to read the answers

Lay the three sets of answers side by side and look for patterns rather than single comments.

"What do we do?" If people describe your main service in roughly the words a customer would use, the headline is doing its job. If they give a vague category ("some kind of design company?"), name a minor service instead of your main one, or simply repeat your slogan back to you, the headline isn't specific enough.

"Who is it for?" Listen for whether they can tell if you work with homeowners or businesses, small jobs or larger projects, a particular trade or sector. If they guess the wrong audience, the page is probably attracting enquiries you don't want and putting off the ones you do.

"Where do we work?" For a South West business serving a defined area, this matters. If nobody can say, or they assume you're national, the area isn't visible near the top. Visitors from your patch may not realise you cover them.

"What would you do next?" This one tells you whether there's a single, clear action. "I'd ring them" or "I'd ask for a quote" is good. "I'd probably look around" or "I'm not sure" suggests the next step is buried or competing with other options.

A simple way to score it: for each question, count how many of the three people got it roughly right. Three out of three means that part is clear. One or none means that's where to start. Two out of three is worth tidying up.

Two cautions. Three people is a quick check, not research, so treat the results as a prompt rather than proof. And if someone dislikes your colours or photos, note it, but don't let it distract you. This test is about clarity, not taste.

A rewrite framework for the top of the homepage

Once you know which questions weren't answered, rewrite the top section using four parts.

1. One plain headline: what you do, and for whom

Say what you do in the words customers use, and who you do it for. It doesn't need to be clever. "Commercial electrical installation and maintenance for businesses" beats "Powering possibility" every time a stranger reads it.

Try writing it as if you were answering "So what do you do?" from someone at a local networking event. Then cut any words that don't add meaning.

2. A supporting line: your area plus one proof point you can back up

Underneath, add a short line that covers where you work and one fact that gives the reader a reason to believe you. Name your counties or towns. For the proof point, use something genuine and checkable: how long you've been trading, an accreditation you actually hold, the type of client or project you typically handle. Avoid anything you couldn't evidence if a customer asked. Vague claims such as "the South West's leading provider" usually weaken the message rather than strengthen it.

3. One primary next step

Choose the single action you most want a suitable visitor to take, and make it the obvious button. Name it by what happens: "Request a site visit", "Ask for a quote", "Book a call". You can keep a phone number visible alongside it, but avoid three or four equal buttons all pulling in different directions.

If you're unsure whether to mention prices near the top, our guide to whether you should show prices on your website goes through the trade-offs.

4. Move the rest further down

This is often the hardest part, because everything on the current homepage is there for a reason. Things that usually work better lower down include:

  • your history and values
  • long lists of every service you offer
  • news, awards and social media feeds
  • welcome messages ("Welcome to our website...")
  • extra slides from a rotating banner

None of this needs to disappear. It just shouldn't sit between a visitor and the answers to the basic questions.

Hypothetical example: before and after

This example is made up to illustrate the framework. It isn't a real business or a client result.

Imagine a family-run joinery workshop near Taunton that makes bespoke kitchens, staircases and fitted furniture for homeowners across Somerset and Devon. It's been trading for many years.

Before (top of the homepage on a phone):

Crafted with passion since day one Welcome to our website. We pride ourselves on quality, attention to detail and outstanding customer service. [Our story] [Gallery] [News] [Contact us]

In the stranger test, all three people guess "furniture" or "some sort of craft business". None knows who it's for or where it works, and two say they'd "look at the gallery".

After:

Bespoke kitchens, staircases and fitted furniture for homeowners Designed and made in our Somerset workshop for homes across Somerset and Devon. Family-run for over 20 years. [Arrange a design visit]

The history, the gallery and the news are all still on the page, just lower down. The headline says what and for whom. The supporting line gives the area and a proof point the owners can genuinely stand behind (in this made-up case, how long they've been trading). There's one obvious next step.

When they rerun the test with three different people, they can see whether the answers improve. If one question still trips people up, they adjust that part and test again.

Is this a quick fix or a bigger job?

For most businesses, this is a wording and layout change. If you can edit your own website, you may be able to rewrite the headline, supporting line and main button in an afternoon, then move a few sections around. If you can't edit it yourself, it's usually a small job for whoever looks after the site.

A deeper rethink is worth considering when the stranger test reveals something bigger than wording, for example:

  • the business has changed what it sells, so the homepage and the pages behind it describe a business you no longer are
  • you serve quite different audiences and the site structure doesn't give each one a clear route
  • the site can't realistically be edited, because the platform is locked, unsupported or nobody has access
  • the top section is fixed by an old template, such as a large slider you can't remove without breaking the layout

In those cases, rewriting the headline may help a little but won't solve the underlying problem. Our guide to whether to refresh or rebuild a website helps you weigh that decision.

And if your homepage passes the stranger test but enquiries are still thin, the problem probably sits further along the journey. Our article on what to check when people visit but don't get in touch walks through the enquiry route step by step.

Try this first

This week, run the stranger test with three people and write their answers down. Count how many got each of the four questions right. Then draft a new headline, supporting line and single button using the framework above, and test again before changing anything else.

Your next step

Westward Digital builds websites and connected lead systems for established businesses across Somerset, Devon, Dorset, Bristol and Bath & North East Somerset. Marcus plans the work directly, and projects start from £4,500. If you've run the stranger test and would like a second opinion on what it's telling you, or whether it's a quick rewrite or something bigger, get in touch for a no-pressure conversation.

Working through something similar?

We can help you work out what to address first.

Start a conversation