How do we know which of our marketing actually brings in enquiries?
Most established businesses spend money and time in several places at once: a website, social media, a directory listing, a local magazine, the odd event. Knowing which of those actually produces enquiries doesn't need new software. Here is a simple lead-source tracking setup you can start this week, and an honest look at its limits.
Ask most business owners where their work comes from and you'll get a confident answer: "mostly word of mouth", or "the website, I think". Sometimes that's right. But when it comes to deciding whether to renew an advert, keep paying for a directory listing or spend another evening on social media, "I think" is an uncomfortable basis for the decision.
This article answers one question: how can you tell which of your marketing is bringing in enquiries? It isn't about what happens to an enquiry once it arrives. If that's your bigger worry, our guide to what should happen after a website enquiry covers it. Here we're focused only on where enquiries come from.
The good news is that you can get a useful answer with tools you almost certainly already have.
Why it's harder than it sounds
Before setting anything up, it helps to be realistic. No tracking method will tell you the whole story, for a few reasons.
- People take winding routes. Someone might hear your name from a neighbour, see your van, look you up on Google months later and then fill in your contact form. Which of those "brought in" the enquiry? Arguably all of them.
- Word of mouth and repeat customers blur things. A returning customer who searches your name and clicks your website will often look like a website enquiry, when really it's loyalty.
- Website analytics can undercount. Under UK rules, most analytics cookies need visitors' consent, and some visitors will decline. The ICO's guidance on cookies and similar technologies explains the rules. In practice, your analytics will usually show fewer visits than really happened.
- People misremember. Ask "how did you hear about us?" and some will guess or pick the first option they see.
None of this makes tracking pointless. It just means you're aiming for a reasonable picture that improves your decisions, not a perfect record. Patterns over a few months matter far more than any single enquiry.
A simple lead-source tracking setup you can start this week
You don't need to do all five steps at once. The first two give you most of the value; the rest are worth adding when they're relevant.
1. Ask "how did you hear about us?"
Add this question to your website enquiry form, and get into the habit of asking it on the phone too. A dropdown with sensible options is easier to analyse than a free-text box. A starting list might be:
- Recommended by someone
- Returning customer
- Google search
- Google Maps or our Google Business Profile
- Social media (you might split this into the platforms you actually use)
- Directory or listings site
- Print advert, magazine or leaflet
- Saw our vehicle, signage or premises
- Event or show
- Other (please tell us)
Keep the list to options that are genuinely relevant to your business. If you've never advertised in print, leave it out. Include "Other" with a short text box so you notice new sources you hadn't thought of.
On the phone, it can feel awkward to ask. A natural moment is near the end: "Just so we know, how did you come across us?" Most people are happy to answer.
2. Add a source column to your enquiry list
Wherever you currently record enquiries, whether that's a spreadsheet, a shared inbox with labels or a notebook, add a "source" field and fill it in for every enquiry using the same options as your form.
If you're using a spreadsheet, these columns are usually enough:
| Date | Name | How they found us | What they asked about | Rough value | Became work? (Yes / No / Pending) |
That last column is the important one. Ten enquiries from one source that never turn into work may be worth less than two from another source that both go ahead.
A spreadsheet is often all you need. If you're getting a manageable number of enquiries each month, a well-kept spreadsheet will answer the question perfectly well. If you're wondering whether you've outgrown one, our article on whether you need a CRM offers a way to decide.
3. Use UTM tags on campaign links
When you share a link to your website in an email newsletter, a social post or a paid advert, you can add a few labels to the end of the link. These are called UTM tags, and website analytics tools such as Google Analytics read them to show where a visit came from.
A tagged link looks like this:
https://www.yourbusiness.co.uk/spring-offer?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=spring-2027
In plain terms:
- utm_source is where the link was placed (for example, newsletter or facebook).
- utm_medium is the type of channel (for example, email, social or paid).
- utm_campaign is the name of the particular campaign or promotion.
You don't need to type these by hand. Google's help article on collecting campaign data with custom URLs explains the tags and links to its free URL builder, where you fill in boxes and it produces the link.
Two practical tips. Agree a naming habit and stick to it, using lower case throughout, because "Facebook" and "facebook" may show up as two separate sources. And don't add UTM tags to links within your own website, only to links you place elsewhere.
Remember the cookie point above: UTM data shows up in analytics only for visitors who allowed analytics cookies, so treat it as a sample.
4. Consider tracked phone numbers or email addresses, if volume justifies it
Some businesses use a separate phone number or email address for a particular channel, such as a dedicated number printed only on a magazine advert. Calls to that number can then only have come from that advert.
This can work well, but it adds cost and admin, and it can confuse people if your number appears differently in different places. It's usually worth considering only when you're spending meaningful sums on a channel and the enquiries it generates mostly arrive by phone. For many businesses, asking "how did you hear about us?" does the same job for free.
5. Hold a monthly 20-minute review
Data that no one looks at changes nothing. Put a short, recurring slot in the diary, perhaps the first Monday of each month, and look at three things:
- What came in? How many enquiries, and roughly what kind.
- From where? Count them by source.
- What turned into work? Which sources produced enquiries that went ahead, and roughly what they were worth.
Then add a one-line note: anything you'll change, stop or try next month. After three or four months you'll start to see whether a pattern is real or a one-off.
A worked example (hypothetical)
This example is entirely hypothetical and is included only to illustrate the process. It does not describe a real business.
Imagine a family-run kitchen fitting business near Taunton. The owners pay for an annual directory listing, run a small advert in a local magazine, post on social media and have a website. They believe most of their work comes from the magazine.
They add a "how did you hear about us?" dropdown to their website form, start asking the question on the phone and add a source column to the spreadsheet they already use. They also tag the link in their monthly email newsletter.
After three months of monthly reviews, they notice that the magazine advert produces a steady trickle of calls, but few of them go ahead. Recommendations and returning customers make up a large share of the jobs that do go ahead, and several people mention finding them through their Google Business Profile.
Rather than cancelling anything immediately, they decide to keep watching for another quarter while putting a little more effort into asking happy customers for reviews. That's a modest, sensible change, based on evidence they didn't have before, and it cost them nothing but a few minutes a week.
When this is enough, and when to do more
For most established businesses, the five steps above are enough. They're cheap, quick to set up and fit into routines you already have.
It may be worth going further, for example connecting your enquiry form directly to a CRM or setting up more detailed analytics, when:
- you're spending significant sums across several paid channels and need to compare them closely;
- enough enquiries come in that recording sources by hand has become a chore that gets skipped;
- several people handle enquiries and the source is regularly lost along the way.
Even then, start by getting the basics working. A connected system can only report on information that's actually captured. And if your problem is that people visit the website but rarely get in touch at all, tracking sources won't fix that; our checklist for when your website gets visits but no enquiries is a better place to start.
A short checklist to start this week
- Add a "how did you hear about us?" dropdown to your enquiry form
- Agree how you'll ask the question on the phone
- Add "source" and "became work?" columns to your enquiry list
- Tag links in your next newsletter or campaign with UTM tags
- Book a recurring 20-minute monthly review in the diary
Your next step
Westward Digital builds websites and connected lead systems for established businesses across Somerset, Devon, Dorset, Bristol and Bath & North East Somerset, and Marcus plans the work directly. If you'd like a second opinion on how your enquiries are captured and tracked, whether that's a small tweak to your form or something more connected, get in touch for a no-pressure conversation.
Working through something similar?
We can help you work out what to address first.